How Then Should We Live?
For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.
Ephesians 2:10
Dear Students, Parents and Carers
The question which frames the beginning of this edition of the Shore Weekly Record was popularised by the philosopher and social commentator Francis Schaeffer in the 1960s as a shorthand summary of his critical interrogation of our world. The question is still highly relevant as we seek from our Building Good Men programme to impart honourable virtues to our boys. Questions of existence and meaning seem more complicated than ever before.
The contemporary philosopher Professor Carl Trueman in his highly influential The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self. Cultural Amnesia, Expressive Individualism and the Road to Sexual Revolution (2020) argues that our modern sense of society prioritises victimhood, sees the self in psychological terms, opposes traditional sexual codes as oppressive and maximises the right of individuals to define their own existence. This leads, he says, to “emotivism”, where ethical discussion is based on a subjective emotional foundation. This, he claims, degenerates into little more than the expression of opinions and preferences. He, therefore, sees sex and sexual preferences as to the forefront in our society, in which there is indefinite flux, instability and incoherence. In this culture, Trueman says, sex is reduced to just a pleasant, biological function with no significance beyond immediate pleasure.
Trueman’s critique raises the question of whether such a weak foundation is acceptable for Shore graduates, or whether something more solid and definite will be necessary to function as a fully formed adult.
Part of Shore’s remit is building into the lives of students. This includes helping them to develop a world view which is sustainable and which leads them to do good; indeed, to serve the world in which they live. “For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do.” (Ephesians 2:10) This, by definition, includes a sense of the good, that is, an ethical framework. As part of this School aspiration, we have invited Professor Hayden Ramsay as our Guest of Honour for the Senior School Speech Day this year, in just seven weeks from now.
Professor Ramsay is Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Education at the Australian Catholic University (ACU), our near neighbour in Edward Street, North Sydney. Part of his role is to lead the ethical framework of the ACU. Prior to his current position, he was Senior Deputy Vice-Chancellor and Professor of Philosophy and Ethics at The University of Notre Dame Australia. Earlier in his academic career, he taught philosophy at a number of universities in Australia and Scotland. Professor Ramsay is a moral philosopher who deeply explores questions of ethics, foundation and meaning. He was very well received by our Year 11 in the activities following our Step Up Camp this year. He is a fine communicator, not only to adults but also to teenagers. In some respects, he is the heir of 1,500 years of outstanding Catholic moral philosophy, an area less explored by Protestant Christians (who had a much later start, i.e. the Reformation of 500 years ago). Speech Day will commence at 10.00am on Friday 8 December 2023 in the R A I Grant Centre.
A further event to note in diaries is our Remembrance Day Service at 10.00am on Saturday 11 November 2023, where our Guest of Honour and Speaker will be the former Governor-General and Head of Australia’s Armed Forces, General Sir Peter Cosgrove.
Dr John Collier
Headmaster

Please note: We encourage expressions of opinion by our Editorial Team without necessarily endorsing or embracing them as a School position; furthermore, boys write in a range of styles, including satirical, and not every critique should be taken literally.