In This Together
Managing the upcoming Social Media Ban for Under 16s
The ban on social media for those under 16 will come into law at the end of 2025. It has been interesting to understand the range of responses to this way forward.
There have been public voices, such as Amnesty International, that have called for the better control of content on the various platforms rather than an age restriction; this is akin to the approach of the European Union in the Digital Services Act which places pressure on the platforms to make them more suitable in their usage by young people. Mental health experts have expressed concern about the removal of access to support groups for marginalised youth which can be found on social media platforms. For instance, the Centre for Multicultural Youth flagged their concerns for those students who have “less access to services and support and [have] relied on social media platforms as a “third place” to spend time. Similarly, a 2021 research paper undertaken by the CSIRO highlighted the direct usage correlation and need of social media for LGBTQ adolescents as they “create a fun and easy way to connect to LGBTQ communities, explore identity and access emotional support…. [where] Peer support has been noted as an important protective factor against poor mental health especially among LGBTQ communities”. Furthermore, Australia’s eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant has raised concerns about the removal of support networks that are critical to some students’ overall wellbeing. As such it is hard to ignore that social media has allowed young people freedom of expression, as well as a place to assemble and mix with peers, (and content-producers and influencers) outside the general controls or community they may experience in their face-to-face lives.
On the other hand, the impact of social media on teenagers has been evident, often with the benefits of community being outweighed by negative impacts on body image, social isolation, healthy sleeping patterns and even cyberbullying. As such, the benefits of reducing the impact of social media doom scrolling are extensive and include:
- With approximately 80% of tweens and teens reporting under sleeping, the removal of such platforms will better provide teens with the opportunity for healthy sleep patterns. Positive sleep patterns directly correlate with improved levels of mental health. Find more information here.
- The reduction of exposure to unhealthy modelling regarding body image, thus improving the overall sense of wellbeing felt by teens. Find more information here.
- With teens moving away from prioritising their digital reputation, and refocusing on further developing their face-to-face interpersonal skills, they will be better prepared for their post-school lives. Find more information here.
- Not using social media will support breaking internet addiction patterns; Dr Michael Carr-Gregg has noted that “giving a smartphone to an 11-year-old can be akin to giving them a ‘loaded gun’” as tween and teen brains are ill-equipped to self-regulate the patterns of consumption that such platforms encourage. Find more information here.
- Bullying has always been a feature of the teenage years. Social media platforms have inherently permitted direct and indirect bullying, as well as trolling, since their inception. No longer will those under 16 have to experience such forms of targeted behaviours. Find more information here.
The groups that will face the greatest challenge of this social media ban are those students who have extensively used it to this point in time but then will no longer be able to. Many students in Years 7, 8 and 9 who currently use social media will no longer be able to have their own accounts from later this year; in contrast, those students in the Primary School should have the smoothest experience due to being the least exposed to such platforms.
For those students who are finding sanctuary in the online world, open conversations at home will be needed. Overuse or dependency on mobile phones and social media can be both a symptom, and exacerbate, poor mental health (find more information here) and its removal may create varying levels of discomfort for students. Furthermore, those teenagers who are in minority communities are vulnerable to the removal of platforms such as Instagram, X and Tik Tok and may find new networks in more ‘at risk’ locations, those less moderated than current platforms. To support this transition, we encourage families to provide active supervision to ensure that their children do not find new, less supervised, spaces on the internet while seeking social connections (find more information here). And if you are about to get a phone for your young daughter, we might suggest the use of “Dumb phones”, a model of phone that is not 4G or 5G enabled, but one that can text and call, rather than being used for social media apps.
Throughout this piece, we have featured a range of resources that are currently available on the SCEGGS website. There is other information available found here. If you have any questions or concerns regarding supporting your child through the introduction of this new legislation, we encourage you to reach out to your daughter’s Year Coordinator, in the secondary school, or your child’s classroom teacher or Sarah Johnstone in the Primary school.
Amy Satchell
Year 9 Co-ordinator